Showing posts with label comment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label comment. Show all posts

9 Sept 2014

Two Days, One Night (Deux Jours, Une Nuit) Review

Well, why not. We all have reviews going round our heads, huh? I did the obligatory going to the pub after watching this to talk it through, and my fellow cinema-goer said he thought it would take no more than half a pint.

"I should have hated it, but I didn't," he said. "But I didn't really care about it, either." 

Now I'm going to write exactly that, in a lot more words (though you can stop reading now if you prefer the abridged version).

We watched it because: We care about ordinary people struggling in an economic down-turn, but mainly because of Time Out's review: 'Most importantly, the film involves us: it draws us into the debate, makes us complicit, demands that we have an opinion, and then upends that same opinion a few minutes later. It's engaging and rousing.'

Two Days, One Night: Not an ordinary film



Sandra is signed off work with depression, but before she is able to return and remind the solar panel company of her value, colleagues vote to lose her in favour of keeping their bonus. She has a weekend to convince them to vote again, and this time, for her to keep her job.

I came to this film without the background a Dardenne Bros aficionado might benefit from, though I did see and love The Kid with a Bike. I know that their forte is thoughtful but bleak social realism, depicting the marginalised through a philosophical lens that makes meaningful fables of fringe life in industrial Belgian communities. It’s not the social realism I object to, but in the case of Two Days, One Night, a wilful lack of realism in other areas.

With every word that might be considered extra cut from exchanges leaving just the barest of expression between one actor and another, it’s like the directors loomed over the cast saying: don’t smile, don’t laugh, even less expression, pull it back. Forget comedy and tragedy being bedfellows. 

Each character is a wisp of a full person, and whilst I love being flattered with the task of filling in the gaps, I didn’t feel there were enough pegs around the board. The characters can be distilled to four statements repeated on a loop:
Sandra: Someone said Jean-Marc influenced the others. Dumont said there could be another vote on Monday
Manu: You can do it, Sandra.
Employees (1): I feel sorry, but I didn’t ask for this. We need my bonus for my… (house/ baby/ electricity…) What do the others say?
Employees (2): I feel sorry, but I didn’t ask for this. I’m not voting against you, I’m voting for my bonus. I earned that money!

Of course you don’t always need a lot of words to make an impact, but I struggled to understand the value of such sparse abstraction. The best part is when Sandra’s friend Timur breaks down from the guilt of having voted against her; the worst part is when Sandra, Manu and Anne sing ‘Rock music’ in the car, breaking away from the film’s rigidity in an uncomfortable manner before returning to their trajectories. When Sandra takes an overdose, a real Manu would have had a more impassioned reaction, but this Manu had to stick to his lines: "You can do it, Sandra."

I thought Marion Cotillard was artful with the material and things rumbled along in a not unpleasantly soporific way, with tiny smiles or face twitches adding much-needed respite. However, the structure and idea had so much promise for depth that I find it hard to forgive the constricted focus and lack of liveliness.  

For me, this film required too much off-camera gap-filling in order to credit it with the monumental substance some reviewers have found in it. I’m a little sick of that technique since Martha, Marcy, May, Marlene wound me up.  

I know that less can often be more, but sometimes less is just less, and I think that allowing the characters to have an ordinary level of personality would have made a good idea into a wonderful movie.

24 Jun 2014

If you do one thing today, walk

There was a woman crying outside of Barclays on Kingsland Road this morning, wailing into her phone and saying she was going to kill herself. She was still wasted from the night before and accosting passers by for help, though she wasn’t sure about what help she needed. ‘Talk to me,’ she begged me, and so I did, and asked her where her home was. It was just by Liverpool St station. She wanted money, but I only had £2; I gave her that. She said her boyfriend beat her, and that she was a normal girl who just wanted to get home. I told her she could walk home by following Kingsland Road down to Shoreditch, and then she’d be close to the station. ‘I don’t want to walk,' she kept saying. I had a good look at her and couldn’t see any reason for her to be stuck by the Balls Pond Road/ Kingsland Road crossroads.

‘Are you going to call the police on me?’ she asked. ‘Of course not,’ I said.
‘I want you to, so they can take me home,’ she said.

What would I say? Someone needs a lift home?

I do that walk all the time. Somehow I felt like there was a connection between the fact she wasn’t prepared to walk a mile or two down a straight road and her Tuesday morning circumstances. If you don’t have the resolve to walk for less than an hour, how can you transport yourself to a different life? I have sympathy, but walking home would have been so simple. ‘Just walk down that road,’ I said again. 'You'll soon see where you are.'

'I don't want to walk,' she objected. 'Can you get me a bus?'

It’s then that I realised that getting into the walking habit is actually far more than just walking. Getting from A to B on your own two feet is sometimes the best thing you can do for yourself.



13 Jun 2014

'Think of them as tents' - Will Self on London's glass behemoths


Will Self: On Architecture

Knowing how I walk into bins because my eyes are on the buildings, my friend Faruk asked me if I fancied going to see Will Self talk about London’s evolving skyline. He, like most people close to me, knows I need to be bought the ticket and told where to be or I’d never go to anything. I’d just walk from one coffee shop to the next, joining up the coffee beans in a hazy, over-caffeinated malaise. 

Will Self is taller than you’d expect even for a tall person, with a face the shape of a California Raisin. He has that appealing grumpy stare that most people with an acerbic wit have, before tossing deadpan words across the room like chest height frisbees.

Will Self is either a genius, or he’s practiced spewing ribbons of alliteration like a rapper masters the ends of lines. Nobody but an orator committed to daily word workouts could speak like Will Self, who uses such long and complicated words he has to chew them a few times before they’re out. I did catch every other word, though. Gherkin. Walkie-Talkie. Shard and ‘like a massive hard-on’. I started enjoying the talk most when he was answering questions as his free-style is both more impressive and more fathomably to the point.

His talk, rather obliquely titled When Liquid Turns to Solid: The Spatialisation of Capital Flows, didn’t have a clear argument for or against London’s new (and Will emphatically maintains, temporary) glass icons, though he seems to be a socialist at heart which of course is at odds with the City by default. In a nutshell, buildings like the Shard are built on (or to attract) flight capital and are throwaway physical manifestations of mammoth money machines. I’m reminded of Elsa in Frozen, when she’s trying to control her runaway magic (which is to unwittingly turn everything to ice) and frostytowers spew from her fingers into a palatial world of cold crystal. They look nice, but will melt.


The first glass skyscrapers were designed (but not built) in 1921 and 1922, by Ludwig Mies Van Der Rohe


New London does look exhilarating, Will said. I’m glad he said that. Not close up, of course, where they’re all done to spec and have a business-world coldness that you don’t want to let creep too deeply into your soul, but he does admit he’s moved his bed for a better view of the Shard. 

Just because they’re temporary doesn’t mean they won’t be replaced by tens more each, and so on. Will says that by 2040 the S-bend of the Thames will be flanked by super structures in our own version of Manhattan. Our solid London logos will project into the sky like Batman beams. Of course it’s exciting and crass in equal measure. Dystopic and almost virtual, since the CAD-designed buildings can’t help but represent the floating virtual world of their in utero phase.  I loved his quip, ‘hit F7 to add a roof garden’. 


The Gherkin has gone bust; last time I heard anything the Shard couldn’t attract tenants. Are these buildings waiting for their time to come, in anticipation of an economic turnaround?


The audience had a lot to say too – clearly made up of design students, architects, town planners, enthusiasts, developers, investors and us. One woman said that the puffed-up bulge of the Walkie-Talkie might be explained by the direct correlation between floor size and money-making capacity. A man mentioned that the Right to Light act makes it easier to get planning permission for developments close to the Thames, and also, this might be why the Walkie Talkie’s girth expands as it rises and obscures less views. At one point Will slipped in a ‘behemoth skyscrapers couldn’t happen in a socialist country’ remark, at which a man in front of me said, ‘What about Russia’; ‘What about China’ – and then there was a murmur-level hoo-hah about whether these countries have ever been socialist in the truly ideological sense (Will thought not).  

Anyway, it was agreeable to listen to Will Self ruminate on architecture, even if I only understood one word in four. 

Is London set to become the new Singapore?


“How about we digest it a bit, before talking about it?” I rather shadily asked Faruk, as we left. Even a good soak in the bath counting ceiling spiders didn't help me piece together more than an impression of what WS really thinks about the impact of the City's changing landscape on the regular guy. I'm happy with just an impression, though. In my over-caffeinated cloud, I'm used to it. And doesn't the skyline look nice from parks?





If anyone else wants a go at explaining his talk to me, you can read an abridged version on the Guardian website.